Costs Of Contentious Probate Proceedings

There is a common misconception that whenever there are Court proceedings concerning the validity of a Will that the costs of all of the parties to the proceedings are paid out of the estate.  This is not correct. 

The question of who is responsible for costs in contentious probate proceedings is a complicated one which can depend upon the particular party to the proceedings.  Executors who adopt a mutual stance and simply do whatever is necessary to establish the validity or otherwise of the Will they have a duty to prove can expect their costs to be paid from the estate in most circumstances but parties to proceedings who are not executors or executors who are also beneficiaries and who therefore have a financial interest in the outcome of the litigation cannot always expect their costs to be paid out of the estate.

Deciphering the rules

The general rule is that each party will be responsible for his or her own costs during the course of the litigation. At the end of the case, the Judge decides which party should pay and the usual rule is that the losing party will pay for both parties. However, on many occasions, costs can be awarded out of the estate.

Are there exceptions?

The Courts acknowledge that in cases of disputed Wills very often the dispute is in no way the fault of any of the parties and a large proportion of the costs may have been incurred in carrying out investigations due to the fact that the principal witness i.e. the maker of the Will has died.  Accordingly in probate cases there are two long established principles which allow Judges to make exceptions to the general costs rule and to make a different Order :

  1. Where the claim is the fault of the deceased such as where there is confusion and uncertainties surrounding the deceased's Will.
  2. Where the circumstances of the particular case raise reasonable grounds for investigation.

The costs have the power to award costs in different ways.

Kostic vs. Chaplin

For example in the case of Kostic vs. Chaplin in 2007 the deceased left £8.2 million to the Conservative Party, thereby disinheriting his son but he also made various comments which called into question whether he had the legal capacity to make a valid Will. The costs of the case were extremely high.

The son won the case and satisfied the Court that his father lacked mental capacity and that therefore the Will was invalid thereby leaving him as the beneficiary of the estate.

The Court took the view, however, that rather than simply award costs against the losing party a different Order was appropriate.

The Court decided that it was entirely appropriate for the Conservative Party Association to make investigations into the deceased's capacity and obtain general information about the claim.  Accordingly up to that point the Association was entitled to receive its costs from the estate.

 
Then from the point at which the Association received the basic information up to the point at which the parties obtained expert evidence in the form of expert's reports each party should be responsible for its own costs. However, from the point at which the Conservative Party Association obtained its expert's report and still decided that the case should go to Court, to the end of the proceedings, the ordinary rule of "loser pays” should apply and the Association should therefore pay the successful party's costs for this period.

The question of costs and who is or who is likely to be responsible for them is therefore a matter which should be considered at the early stage of contested proceedings.

Contact Clough & Willis

The approachable and experienced solicitors at Clough & Willis are best placed to offer support and guidance when it comes to deciphering who is responsible for the costs of probate proceedings.  We understand that legal proceedings can be stressful, but we are on hand every step of the way. We have handled cases across Bolton and Bury, helping families to reach the conclusion they deserve.

To discuss your circumstances with a qualified, legal specialist, contact us by calling 0800 083 0815, or complete an online enquiry form and we will be in touch.

What Our Clients Say

I was very impressed with Sallys patient, knowledgeable ideas and explanations. The law can be very confusing. Her genuine wish to help was much appreciated.

Mrs Baumber

I am part sighted and things that I have found hard to read have been read to me with understanding and patience. I feel well served.

Mrs Parkinson

I am now happy that my will and Lasting Power of Attorney has been prepared by a solicitor. In past years it was through the bank. They are not solicitors. Now I can see the difference, Miss Sally Cook was so professional and very thorough from start to finish. A very big thank you to Sally for everything. Also thank you to Clough & Willis Solicitors.

Mrs Wareing

Everything that they did was done without any bother at all. Their professionalism could not be improved.

Mr Greaves

Very satisfied with the service from Sally Cook - very helpful and professional

Mr & Mrs McColgan

We found the whole process quick and stress free! Sally Cook was both professional and efficient and we were very pleased with the service we received.

Mrs Halliwell

I was very pleased to meet with Sally Cook, for her to prepare my complete new Will, and Lasting Power of Attorney. It was not easy for me to understand all of that, but Sally guided me through. Sally took the time to explain to me the content of both, nothing was too much trouble and I can't thank her enough for everything she did. From myself thank you so much Sally.

Mr R Wareing

Sally Cook was very professional and explained to me what a Will consisted off and dealt with the matter quickly and very efficiently would recommend to anyone.

Miss T Wareing

Sally was helpful, friendly, professional and very approachable. I felt completely at ease and important to her as a client. Keep up the good work.

Mrs Matthews

They were very kind to me when my husband died.

Mrs Garner

Many thanks to Sally for the excellent service we received.

Mr Meadowcroft

I found Sally Cook to be very helpful, approachable and professional.

Mrs Gilbert

Thank you to Rebecca for showing much empathy and sensitivity at a very difficult time for our family.

Mr Lomax

I wish to thank Rebecca Green for her kind and friendly approach to my requirements, she made me feel relaxed from the very start and was extremely informative to everything I asked her. Many thanks Rebecca.

Mr Fairfield

I felt completely at ease with Rebecca. Despite her professional status I didn’t feel at all intimidated. She took charge in a respectful manner.

Mrs Yates

I was very pleased with the way Rebecca Green dealt with the making of my Will. She was thorough in her explanations and made me feel she was really experienced in her work. I would have no hesitation in recommending her.

Mrs Chatburn

Rebecca was extremely helpful and friendly in my making a new will, also a very nice person to meet.

Ms Fitzsimmons

I was made to feel welcome and Rebecca made me feel more like a friend than a client.

Ms Hedley

Rebecca is very good at explaining all the issues concerning making a Will. She dealt with my case efficiently and she has a very friendly manner.

Ms Bird

Rebecca was helpful and informative but she also gave us time to think things over without time pressure – thank you.

Mr & Mrs Harrington

My husband and I were very pleased and impressed by Ms Green when she came to our home she was very patient and helpful.

Mrs Lloyd

Rebecca is to be highly commended for her friendly and highly professional approach. She represents a real asset to your firm.

Mr Nugent

Read all testimonials